Top 15 Milkshakes In Upper West Side Nyc

Nathan Jahnke

2 min read

·

30-12-2024

11

0

Share

The Upper West Side, a neighborhood brimming with culture and history, also boasts a surprisingly diverse milkshake scene. Beyond the classic diner fare, you'll find innovative and decadent creations that will satisfy even the most discerning milkshake aficionado. This list compiles fifteen of the best, categorized for easier navigation.

Classic Creaminess:

1. JJ Diner: A true Upper West Side institution, JJ Diner offers classic thick milkshakes in a variety of traditional flavors. Expect generous portions and a nostalgic atmosphere.

2. Zabar's: This iconic gourmet food store surprisingly offers some of the best classic milkshakes in the neighborhood. Their creamy texture and simple perfection make them a worthy contender.

3. Cafe Luxembourg: This elegant bistro provides a sophisticated take on the classic milkshake, emphasizing high-quality ingredients and a refined presentation.

Gourmet & Innovative:

4. Ample Hills Creamery: Known for their creative and often whimsical flavors, Ample Hills offers unique milkshake experiences that are as delicious as they are inventive.

5. Morgenstern's Finest Ice Cream: This artisanal ice cream parlor takes milkshakes to a new level, utilizing high-quality ingredients and unusual flavor combinations for a truly memorable treat.

6. The Smith: This popular restaurant offers a curated milkshake menu featuring seasonal and unique flavor combinations.

Fruity & Refreshing:

7. Sweet Melissa Patisserie: This charming patisserie offers refreshing fruit-based milkshakes, perfect for a lighter treat.

8. Max Brenner Chocolate Bar: While known for their chocolate, Max Brenner also boasts decadent fruit-infused milkshakes that offer a delightful balance of sweet and tart.

Chocolate Decadence:

9. Magnolia Bakery: Their famous banana pudding inspiration translates beautifully into a rich and decadent chocolate milkshake.

10. Levain Bakery: While primarily known for their cookies, Levain Bakery occasionally offers unique chocolate milkshake options that shouldn't be missed.

Unique & Unexpected:

11. Balthazar: This iconic French brasserie offers a surprisingly delightful milkshake on their dessert menu, blending classic French flavors with milkshake indulgence.

12. Sarabeth's: Sarabeth's offers a unique range of milkshakes, often featuring seasonal fruits and spices, creating a surprising and refreshing taste experience.

Coffee & Caffeine Kicks:

13. Think Coffee: This popular coffee shop occasionally features unique coffee-infused milkshakes that provide both a caffeine and milkshake fix.

Boozy Delights (for those 21+):

14. The Skylark: This rooftop bar features sophisticated cocktails, including adult milkshakes that elevate the classic treat to a new level.

15. The Beatrice Inn: This intimate and stylish bar offers unique boozy milkshake concoctions that are perfect for a night out.

Note: Availability of specific milkshake flavors and options may vary depending on the season and the establishment's menu. It's always best to check with the venue before your visit. Enjoy your Upper West Side milkshake adventure!