The Counting Room Reviews Menu Williamsburg Nyc

Nathan Jahnke

2 min read

·

20-12-2024

9

0

Share

The Counting Room, nestled in the vibrant heart of Williamsburg, Brooklyn, isn't your typical gastropub. While it certainly boasts a robust selection of craft beers and an inviting atmosphere, the true star of the show is its unexpectedly sophisticated menu. This review delves into the culinary offerings, exploring both the highs and lows of this popular Williamsburg establishment.

Ambiance and Atmosphere

Stepping into The Counting Room feels like stepping into a cozy, dimly lit sanctuary. The décor is a blend of rustic charm and modern industrial chic, creating a space equally suited for a casual after-work drink or a more formal dinner. The low lighting and comfortable seating contribute to a relaxed, almost intimate atmosphere, making it an excellent spot for conversation.

The Menu: A Balancing Act

The Counting Room menu is a fascinating blend of elevated comfort food and more adventurous dishes. It's clear that considerable thought has gone into the sourcing of ingredients, with a noticeable emphasis on fresh, seasonal produce.

Highlights:

• The Charred Octopus: Tender and flavorful, expertly charred to perfection, this dish showcased a masterful understanding of simple yet effective seasoning. It was a true highlight of the meal.
• The Lobster Mac and Cheese: A decadent indulgence, this dish is a testament to the restaurant's ability to elevate classic comfort food. The lobster was generous, and the cheese sauce was rich and creamy without being overly heavy.
• The Roasted Chicken: A seemingly simple dish executed with exceptional precision. The chicken was juicy and flavorful, with perfectly crisp skin. A testament to classic culinary techniques.

Areas for Improvement:

• The Burger: While not bad, the burger felt somewhat unremarkable compared to the other dishes. The patty was cooked well, but lacked a distinctive flavor profile that would elevate it above other similar offerings in the neighborhood.
• Dessert Selection: The dessert menu felt a little limited, offering only a few options. Expanding this section with more variety would greatly enhance the overall dining experience.

Service and Value

The service at The Counting Room was attentive and friendly, without being intrusive. Staff were knowledgeable about the menu and happy to offer recommendations. While not inexpensive, the overall value for the quality of food and ambiance felt appropriate.

Conclusion: A Worthwhile Culinary Stop

The Counting Room offers a compelling dining experience in Williamsburg. While a few minor improvements could be made, the overall quality of the food, the inviting atmosphere, and the attentive service make it a worthwhile destination for anyone seeking a sophisticated yet relaxed culinary experience. The menu showcases a balanced approach to gastropub fare, offering both comforting familiarity and exciting culinary adventures. It’s certainly a place I'd happily recommend and revisit.