The 12 Best Italian Restaurants In Brooklyn Heights New York City

Nathan Jahnke

2 min read

·

23-12-2024

12

0

Share

Brooklyn Heights boasts a vibrant culinary scene, and its Italian restaurants are a testament to this. From classic red-sauce joints to modern interpretations of Italian cuisine, there's a perfect pasta dish or pizza slice waiting for every palate. This guide highlights twelve of the best, offering a diverse range of experiences and price points. Our selections were made based on extensive research, reviews, and firsthand experiences, ensuring accuracy and reflecting the current culinary landscape.

Top Tier Trattorias:

1. Anella: This intimate spot offers a refined tasting menu experience, showcasing seasonal ingredients and impeccable technique. Expect innovative dishes and a sophisticated atmosphere.

2. Cecconi's Dumbo: While technically in Dumbo, its proximity to Brooklyn Heights and its high caliber make it worth including. Cecconi's delivers classic Italian dishes with a modern twist, situated in a stunning waterfront location.

3. Grimaldi's Pizzeria: A Brooklyn institution, Grimaldi's is famous for its coal-fired pizzas. While not strictly a trattoria, its iconic status and undeniable deliciousness merit its inclusion. Be prepared for a wait, but the pizza is worth it.

Neighborhood Gems:

4. Juliana's Pizza: Located near Grimaldi's, Juliana's offers a compelling alternative, with a slightly different style of coal-fired pizza. Many consider it a worthy rival.

5. River Café: Offering breathtaking views of the Manhattan skyline, the River Café delivers an upscale Italian dining experience. Expect impeccable service and an unforgettable ambiance.

6. DeStefano's Steak House: While primarily known for its steaks, DeStefano's also offers excellent Italian-American dishes, making it a great option for a more diverse menu.

Casual & Comfortable:

7. Pizza Moto: A popular spot for casual pizza and other Italian favorites, Pizza Moto offers a relaxed atmosphere and quick service. Perfect for a quick and satisfying meal.

8. Foragers City Market: Though a market, Foragers offers high-quality prepared Italian foods and has a great takeout selection for an easy Italian night in.

9. Henry's End: This stylish establishment offers elevated Italian-American fare in a refined-casual setting. A good choice for a celebratory meal or special occasion.

Hidden Treasures:

10. Bar Bruno: This cozy spot is ideal for enjoying classic Italian cocktails and small plates in an intimate setting. Perfect for a pre-dinner drink or a late-night bite.

Pizza Perfection (Beyond the Big Names):

11. Lucali: This no-frills pizzeria is a legendary spot for its simple yet incredibly delicious pizzas. Be prepared for a long wait but the pizza is worth the anticipation.

A Sweet Ending:

12. Brooklyn Heights Pastry Shop: While not strictly a restaurant, no list of Brooklyn Heights culinary delights would be complete without mentioning this bakery, offering a delightful range of Italian pastries and desserts.

This list offers a diverse selection, reflecting the richness and variety of Italian dining options in Brooklyn Heights. Remember to check restaurant websites or call ahead for reservations, particularly for popular establishments. Buon appetito!