New Cottage Reviews Menu Upper West Side Nyc

2 min read 20-12-2024

New Cottage Reviews Menu Upper West Side Nyc

New Cottage, nestled in the heart of the Upper West Side, has quickly become a neighborhood favorite. But what exactly makes this spot so appealing? Let's delve into a review of their menu, exploring the dishes that have garnered praise and those that might leave you wanting more.

Atmosphere and Ambiance

Before we jump into the food, it's important to note the inviting atmosphere. New Cottage boasts a cozy, charming ambiance perfect for a romantic dinner or a casual night out with friends. The decor is understated yet elegant, creating a relaxed and sophisticated setting. The service, in our experience, was consistently attentive and friendly, adding to the overall positive experience.

A Menu for Every Taste

New Cottage's menu is surprisingly diverse, offering a range of options to satisfy various palates. From classic comfort food with a modern twist to more adventurous dishes showcasing seasonal ingredients, there's something for everyone.

Starters: A Delightful Beginning

The appetizers are a strong point. The Burrata with Roasted Tomatoes and Pesto is a standout, the creamy burrata perfectly complementing the sweet tomatoes and vibrant pesto. The Crispy Calamari is another popular choice, tender and perfectly fried, served with a zesty aioli. While we found both to be excellent, the portion sizes for the appetizers could be considered slightly small for the price.

Main Courses: A Mix of Hits and Misses

The main courses are where New Cottage shows both its strengths and weaknesses. The Pan-Seared Salmon is consistently praised for its perfectly cooked flaky texture and flavorful presentation. The accompanying vegetables are fresh and well-seasoned. However, the Beef Bourguignon, while flavorful, lacked the richness and depth one might expect from this classic French dish. The meat was tender, but the sauce was somewhat thin and lacked the robust body of a traditional preparation.

Desserts: Sweet Endings

The dessert menu offers a tempting selection of sweet treats. The Chocolate Lava Cake is a rich and decadent indulgence, perfectly molten in the center. The Lemon Tart, while lighter, offers a refreshing contrast to the richer options. Both desserts are beautifully presented and expertly prepared.

Overall Impression

New Cottage offers a pleasant dining experience on the Upper West Side. While some dishes shine brighter than others, the overall quality of food, coupled with the inviting atmosphere and attentive service, makes it a worthwhile destination. However, potential diners should be aware that prices are on the higher end for the area, reflecting the quality of ingredients and ambiance. It's a great option for a special occasion or a celebratory meal, but perhaps less ideal for a budget-friendly everyday dining experience.