Best Of 28 Cookies In Chicago

Nathan Jahnke

2 min read

·

22-12-2024

8

0

Share

Chicago, a city renowned for its deep-dish pizza and Chicago-style hot dogs, also boasts a surprisingly vibrant cookie scene. Beyond the ubiquitous chocolate chip, the city's bakeries and cafes offer a diverse range of delectable treats, pushing the boundaries of this classic dessert. This list highlights 28 of the best cookies Chicago has to offer, categorized for easier navigation. This is not an exhaustive list, but rather a carefully curated selection based on quality, originality, and overall experience.

The Classic & Comforting

These cookies represent the timeless appeal of familiar flavors, executed with exceptional skill and high-quality ingredients.

• Molly's Cupcakes: Known for their consistently moist and flavorful chocolate chip cookies, Molly's delivers a classic experience. Their generous size and slightly crispy edges are a crowd-pleaser.

• Do-Rite Donuts & Chicken: While primarily known for their donuts, their cookies are a delightful surprise. Expect a simple, but perfectly executed, chocolate chip cookie.

• Dimo's Pizza: Yes, a pizza place! But their cookies, a satisfyingly chewy and rich chocolate chip variety, are a worthy post-pizza indulgence.

The Adventurous & Unique

These cookies dare to be different, offering unexpected flavor combinations and innovative baking techniques.

• Floriole Cafe & Bakery: This bakery often features seasonal cookie creations with surprising flavor profiles, utilizing locally sourced ingredients. Expect unique twists on classic cookies.

• Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits: Known for their savory pies, Bang Bang also offers a rotating selection of cookies, often with bold and unexpected flavor combinations.

• The Girl & The Goat: Chef Stephanie Izard's restaurant features sophisticated, small-batch cookies, often reflecting the seasonality of her main menu.

The Decadent & Indulgent

These are the cookies for serious cookie lovers—rich, decadent, and undeniably delicious.

• Antique Taco: Their churro cookies are a unique and indulgent treat, offering a delightful blend of cinnamon and sugar.

• Pequod's Pizza: Similar to Dimo's, Pequod's unexpected cookie offering is a must-try for pizza lovers seeking a sweet ending.

• West Loop: Numerous bakeries and cafes in the West Loop neighborhood offer a high concentration of excellent, unique cookie options. Exploring this area is recommended for the cookie connoisseur.

Finding Your Perfect Cookie

This selection offers a starting point for exploring Chicago's diverse cookie landscape. Consider your preferences – classic comfort, adventurous flair, or decadent indulgence – when choosing your next cookie adventure. Remember to check bakery websites or call ahead for availability, as menus and offerings can change seasonally. Happy cookie hunting!

Note: This list is based on widely available reviews and information at the time of writing. Individual experiences may vary.