Best Of 20 Pizza Places In Upper West Side Nyc

Nathan Jahnke

2 min read

·

23-12-2024

11

0

Share

The Upper West Side boasts a diverse culinary scene, and pizza, that quintessential New York food, is no exception. Finding the perfect slice can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack, but fear not! We've compiled a list of twenty exceptional pizza places in the UWS, catering to a variety of tastes and budgets. From classic New York-style to innovative gourmet pies, this guide will help you navigate the delicious landscape of Upper West Side pizza.

A Slice of Heaven: Our Top 20 Picks

This list is not ranked in order of preference, as taste is subjective. Instead, it highlights the unique qualities of each pizzeria, allowing you to choose the best fit for your craving.

1. Joe's Pizza: A UWS institution, known for its classic, thin-crust pies and consistently reliable quality. Expect long lines, but the wait is often worth it.

2. Sal & Carmine's: A family-run establishment serving up generous slices and whole pies with a friendly atmosphere.

3. Emmy Squared: This trendy spot offers creative, gourmet pizzas with unique toppings and a modern twist on the classic.

4. Paulie Gee's: A renowned pizzeria with a focus on artisanal ingredients and Neapolitan-style pies. Expect a slightly higher price point, but the quality reflects it.

5. Artichoke Basille's Pizza: Famous for its decadent artichoke pizza, a must-try for adventurous eaters.

6. Pizza Suprema: A long-standing favorite offering a wide variety of classic and specialty pizzas.

7. Leo's Bagels: While primarily known for its bagels, Leo's also serves up surprisingly good pizza, making it a convenient option for a quick bite.

8. V&T Pizzeria: Offers both classic and unique pizza combinations in a casual, family-friendly setting.

9. Westside Pizza: A local gem, beloved by residents for its affordable prices and consistently good pizza.

10. 2 Bros Pizza: Known for their late-night hours and generous slices, perfect for a post-show or late-night snack.

11. Pisticci: A higher-end option with a focus on quality ingredients and a refined menu.

12. Zabar's: While primarily a gourmet food store, Zabar's also serves pizza, providing a convenient option for shoppers.

13. Little Italy Pizza: A small, neighborhood pizzeria offering traditional New York-style pies.

14. Prince Street Pizza: (While technically not on the UWS, its proximity and reputation warrant inclusion.) Renowned for its thin crust and delicious Sicilian slices.

15. Good Enough to Eat: Primarily a bakery, but their pizzas are surprisingly delicious.

16. La Piazza: An Italian restaurant offering authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas in a more upscale setting.

17. Anella: Offers unique and creative pizza options in a more stylish setting, with a focus on fresh ingredients.

18. Via Emilia: While an Italian restaurant first and foremost, their pizzas are worth a try for those seeking a more refined experience.

19. Boulud Sud: A more expensive option, this higher-end restaurant offers gourmet pizzas as part of their extensive menu.

20. Don Antonio by Starita a Materdei: Offers authentic Neapolitan pizza, cooked in a wood-fired oven, for a truly authentic experience.

Finding Your Perfect Slice

This list provides a diverse range of options, from casual slices to upscale gourmet pizzas. Explore the options, read reviews, and discover your new favorite Upper West Side pizza spot! Remember to check hours and availability before heading out. Happy eating!