Best Of 15 Milkshakes In Midtown Nyc

Nathan Jahnke

2 min read

·

30-12-2024

16

0

Share

Midtown Manhattan, a whirlwind of skyscrapers and hurried footsteps, also offers a surprisingly sweet escape: the perfect milkshake. Beyond the ubiquitous coffee chains, a hidden world of creamy concoctions awaits the discerning milkshake aficionado. This list highlights fifteen of the best, offering a diverse range of flavors and styles to satisfy any craving. From classic chocolate to innovative creations, these milkshakes are worth seeking out during your next Midtown adventure.

The Contenders: A Diverse Lineup

This list isn't ranked; each milkshake offers a unique experience. The "best" milkshake is subjective and depends on individual preference. We've included a variety of styles to cater to diverse tastes.

Classic & Creamy:

1. The Smith: Known for its upscale American fare, The Smith also boasts a remarkably rich and creamy classic chocolate milkshake. Expect high-quality ingredients and a satisfyingly thick texture.
2. Junior's Restaurant: A Midtown institution, Junior's is famous for its cheesecake, but their milkshakes deserve equal attention. Their classic flavors are undeniably decadent.
3. Ellen's Stardust Diner: While the singing waiters are the main draw, don't overlook the surprisingly good milkshakes at this unique diner. They are a perfect complement to the retro atmosphere.

Gourmet & Innovative:

4. Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer: Black Tap's over-the-top milkshakes are Instagram-worthy creations. Prepare for towering confections loaded with sweets and toppings.
5. Serendipity 3: This iconic spot is synonymous with extravagant desserts, and their milkshakes live up to the reputation. Expect unique flavor combinations and impressive presentations.
6. Milk Bar: Christina Tosi's Milk Bar offers inventive and playful milkshake creations that reflect her signature style. These are not your grandmother's milkshakes.

Coffee Shop Delights:

7. La Colombe Coffee Roasters: La Colombe isn't just about coffee; their milkshakes showcase their commitment to high-quality ingredients. Expect a sophisticated and smooth experience.
8. Gregory's Coffee: A local favorite, Gregory's Coffee offers reliably delicious milkshakes at a reasonable price. A perfect pick-me-up during a busy day.

Unique & Unexpected:

9. Shake Shack: While a chain, Shake Shack consistently delivers a solid milkshake experience. Their classic flavors are consistently creamy and well-balanced.
10. Morgenstern's Finest Ice Cream: This artisanal ice cream shop offers handcrafted milkshakes made with their exceptional ice cream. Expect a truly premium experience.

International Flavors:

11. Ample Hills Creamery: Ample Hills features unique and creative flavors, often incorporating international influences. Their milkshakes are a testament to their innovative approach to ice cream.
12. Van Leeuwen Artisan Ice Cream: Van Leeuwen offers a globally-inspired menu, and their milkshakes are no exception. Expect interesting flavor combinations and high-quality ingredients.

Casual & Convenient:

13. Chipotle: Yes, Chipotle! While not their primary offering, their milkshakes are a surprisingly good option for a quick and easy treat.
14. Five Guys: Similar to Chipotle, Five Guys provides a solid, no-frills milkshake experience. A straightforward and satisfying option.

A Hidden Gem:

15. (Insert Local Gem Here): Every neighborhood holds a hidden gem, a small, unassuming spot with a surprisingly delicious milkshake. Do some exploring and discover your own favorite!

Choosing Your Perfect Shake

The best milkshake for you depends on your preferences. Consider your desired level of sweetness, thickness, and the flavors you enjoy. Don't be afraid to try something new! Midtown Manhattan offers a world of milkshake possibilities waiting to be explored.