Best Of 14 Pizza Places In Upper East Side Nyc

2 min read 23-12-2024

Best Of 14 Pizza Places In Upper East Side Nyc

The Upper East Side, known for its upscale boutiques and elegant brownstones, also boasts a surprisingly diverse pizza scene. Forget the stereotypical greasy slice; this neighborhood offers everything from classic New York-style pies to innovative, gourmet creations. Choosing the best can be overwhelming, so we've compiled a list of 14 exceptional pizza places, catering to various tastes and budgets.

A Slice of Heaven: Our Top Picks

This list isn't ranked in order of preference, as taste is subjective. Instead, we highlight the unique characteristics of each establishment, allowing you to choose the perfect pizza experience based on your craving.

Classic New York Style:

Joe's Pizza: A true institution, Joe's delivers on the promise of a classic, foldable New York slice. Expect generous toppings and a satisfyingly crispy crust. Their simplicity is their strength.
Paulie Gee's: While not strictly adhering to the classic New York style, Paulie Gee's offers expertly crafted pies with a focus on quality ingredients and creative topping combinations. It’s a step up from the everyday slice.

Gourmet & Unique:

Emily: This trendy spot elevates pizza to an art form. Their creative toppings and perfectly charred crusts are a must-try for pizza aficionados. Expect higher prices but exceptional quality.
Pizzeria Bianco (NYC): A branch of the acclaimed Arizona pizzeria, Pizzeria Bianco offers a unique take on pizza with its thin, crispy crust and carefully sourced ingredients. The wait can be long, but it’s worth it.

Casual & Convenient:

Prince Street Pizza (UES location): Known for its consistently delicious and affordable slices, Prince Street Pizza is perfect for a quick and satisfying meal. It's a reliable choice for a casual bite.
Artichoke Basille's Pizza: If you're a fan of unique and creamy pizza, this is the place to go. Their artichoke pizza is a fan favorite, though they offer a variety of other options.

Other Notable Mentions:

The Upper East Side’s diverse culinary landscape extends to its pizza choices. These locations offer different styles, price points and unique experiences.

Spoleto: Offers a build-your-own pizza option, allowing for complete customization.
Pizza Beach: A laid-back option with a good selection of pies and sides.
Via Tribunali: Known for its Neapolitan-style pizzas, cooked in a wood-fired oven.
Lilia: Although known more for its pasta, Lilia's pizzas are highly regarded for their quality ingredients and excellent execution. Reservations are strongly recommended.
Rubirosa: A classic New York pizzeria with a bustling atmosphere and consistently good pizza.
2 Bros Pizza: Offering a quick and affordable slice, 2 Bros Pizza is a popular choice for a casual meal.
Good Pizza: Lives up to its name with quality ingredients and a well-executed crust.
Scarr's Pizza: Offering unique and delicious pizza in a cozy setting.

Finding Your Perfect Slice

The Upper East Side’s pizza scene is vibrant and diverse, offering something for everyone. Whether you crave a classic New York slice or a gourmet creation, this list provides a starting point for your pizza adventure. Remember to check hours and consider making reservations, especially during peak times. Happy eating!