12 Best Italian Restaurants In Long Island New York City155

Nathan Jahnke

2 min read

·

23-12-2024

10

0

Share

Long Island boasts a vibrant culinary scene, and Italian food holds a particularly prominent place. From classic red-sauce joints to upscale trattorias, the island offers a diverse range of Italian dining experiences. This list highlights twelve of the best, catering to various tastes and budgets. Note that "Long Island" and "New York City" are distinct geographical areas; this list focuses on restaurants located on Long Island.

A Diverse Selection for Every Palate

This selection prioritizes quality, authenticity, and overall dining experience. Restaurants are not ranked in order of preference, as individual tastes vary greatly.

Upscale Experiences

1. A Mano: Known for its refined ambiance and modern take on classic Italian dishes, A Mano offers an elevated dining experience. Expect impeccable service and expertly crafted pasta.

2. Il Giardino: This elegant establishment provides a sophisticated setting for enjoying traditional Italian fare. Their wine list is extensive, complementing their menu perfectly.

3. Posto: Posto combines contemporary design with a menu that balances innovation and tradition. Their commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients is evident in every dish.

Casual & Classic

4. Carbone's: A Long Island institution, Carbone's serves hearty, classic Italian-American dishes in a warm and welcoming atmosphere. It's a perfect choice for a family meal.

5. Scala's: Known for its generous portions and timeless recipes, Scala's delivers a satisfying and affordable Italian-American dining experience.

6. Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza: While known for pizza, Anthony's also offers delicious Italian-American entrees and appetizers in a casual setting.

Hidden Gems & Neighborhood Favorites

7. LiVe: This restaurant offers a unique and creative approach to Italian cuisine, blending tradition with modern flair. It's a great place to discover new flavors.

8. La Piazza: This charming restaurant provides a cozy and authentic Italian atmosphere. They are known for their fresh pasta and friendly service.

Pizza Perfection

9. Luigi's: A local favorite for its consistently excellent pizza, Luigi's also offers a full menu of Italian-American staples.

10. Emilia's: A popular choice for pizza lovers, Emilia's is praised for its high-quality ingredients and creative pizza combinations.

Beyond the Expected

11. Bocca: Bocca provides a more modern, innovative twist on Italian cuisine, using locally sourced ingredients where possible. Expect stylish presentations and creative flavor combinations.

12. Porto Bello: Porto Bello offers a sophisticated take on Italian-Mediterranean cuisine, with a focus on fresh seafood and vibrant flavors.

Finding Your Perfect Italian Escape

This list provides a starting point for exploring Long Island's exceptional Italian restaurants. Remember to check restaurant websites or call ahead for reservations, especially during peak hours. Enjoy your culinary journey!